It is somewhat ironic that a website dedicated to “Intelligent Design” is increasingly unable to have intelligent discussions. The site I’m talking about is “Uncommon Descent“, the blog of uber-ID proponents William Dembski and Denyse O’Leary. In recent posts, “Uncommon Descent” has brought Hitler into the discussion in an attempt to equivocate the reprehensible acts of Hitler with the theory of evolution.
It is true that Hitler believed in evolution, and was a big proponent of “social Darwinism”. It is also true that Hitler was a vegetarian and born in the month of April. Does this mean that anyone who has given up meat is as evil as Hitler? Do people born in April have a higher propensity to send Jews to the gas chamber?
To think that vegetarians and people born in April are anything like Hitler is absurd. It is just as absurd to link evolution to Hitler. In a recent post, O’Leary opines “My own view is that the reason for the controversy around films like the Coral Ridge special is precisely the fact that Darwinists have never really dealt with the implications of social Darwinism, so it keeps coming back to them like a bad penny.”
Actually, “social Darwinism” has been dead for over sixty years now, and in historical hindsight, it appears that “social Darwinism” was only co-opted by imperialist and racist movements to attempt to sound scientifically legitimate. Even today, the remaining “social Darwinists” are nothing more than a fringe movement.
O’Leary, of course, is completely wrong when she claims “Darwinists” haven’t dealt with the implications of “social Darwinism.” One just has to look at Secular Humanism to see just how much it has been dealt with . By bringing up Hitler, though, O’Leary hopes to paint “Darwinists” as cold, unfeeling, immoral hedonists with hearts like Adolf. It’s cheap at best, and repugnant at worst.
Why is O’Leary reduced to cheap Hitler attacks? I’m not sure, but I think it has something to do with her own realization of how weak and sad the foundations of “Intelligent Design” are. That might be the most intelligent thing she’s ever thought.
Share and Enjoy:
These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.